EcomBeatsSearch tools and comparisonsCtrl KSubmit a tool

AfterShip vs ShipStation: shipping costs compared

Short answer

Stores shipping up to 100 orders a month

ShipStation ShipStation Starter costs $29.99 a month at 100 shipments, against $39 for AfterShip Shipping Essentials.

Stores shipping 500 or more orders a month

AfterShip AfterShip Shipping Essentials stays $39 a month up to 1,000 shipments, while ShipStation Starter costs $39.99 at 500 shipments and $79.99 at 1,000.

Stores that want branded tracking as the main job

AfterShip AfterShip Tracking Essentials costs $49 a month and tracks 2,000+ carriers, with AI delivery dates on Premium at $99 a month.

Stores selling on several marketplaces from one dashboard

ShipStation ShipStation connects unlimited stores and names TikTok Shop, Amazon and Walmart, with automation rules on the $14.99 Starter plan.

Stores that need a branded returns portal without a separate returns bill

ShipStation ShipStation adds its branded returns portal on Standard at $29.99 a month, while AfterShip Returns Essentials costs $205 a month.

Pick ShipStation up to 100 shipments a month: Starter costs $14.99 for 50 shipments and $29.99 for 100, against $39 for AfterShip Shipping Essentials. From 500 shipments, pick AfterShip: Shipping Essentials stays $39 for up to 1,000 shipments while ShipStation Starter reaches $39.99 at 500 and $79.99 at 1,000. AfterShip also rates higher at 4.6 stars against 4.3, and tracks 2,000+ carriers.

Choose AfterShip if

  • you want branded tracking and delivery updates across 2,000+ carriers
  • you ship 500 or more orders a month and want labels at a flat $39 a month
Read the full AfterShip details

Choose ShipStation if

  • you ship up to 100 orders a month and want the lowest entry price at $14.99 a month
  • you sell on several marketplaces and want every order in one dashboard
Read the full ShipStation details

AfterShip vs ShipStation at a glance

CompareAfterShipShipStation
EcomBeats scoreNot rated yet7.3 out of 10
Cheapest paid plan$39/mo (Shipping Essentials)$14.99/mo (Starter)
Cost at 100 shipments a month$39/mo$29.99/mo
Cost at 500 shipments a month$39/mo$39.99/mo
Cost at 1,000 shipments a month$39/mo$79.99/mo
Rating4.6 stars (1,514 reviews)4.3 stars (710 reviews)
Free planFree plan availableNone listed
Free trial7 days (Tracking)30 days (every plan)
Carriers covered2,000+ carriers tracked200+ carriers for rates
Branded tracking pageTracking Essentials ($49/mo)From Standard ($29.99/mo)
Branded returns portalReturns Essentials ($205/mo)From Standard ($29.99/mo)
Bulk label printingShipping Essentials ($39/mo)Starter ($14.99/mo)
Discounted carrier rates100+ carriers (Shipping)200+ carriers
Inventory managementNot listedAdvanced, on Premium ($349.99/mo)
LTL freightNot listedParcel and LTL in one platform
Uptime guarantee99.9% monthly uptime guaranteeNot listed
Phone supportNot listedFrom Standard ($29.99/mo)
App languages51
Live chat supportLive chat and emailEmail and chat on Starter
Store connectionsMulti-store on Enterprise (custom)Unlimited on every plan
Links

Source: AfterShip Pricing: Tracking, Returns and Shipping Plans, ShipStation Pricing, AfterShip Tracking and Returns on the Shopify App Store, ShipStation Orders and Inventory on the Shopify App Store and AfterShip Tracking and Returns reviews on the Shopify App Store. The EcomBeats score averages pricing, features, support and merchant reviews, each out of 10. How we rate

What AfterShip does

AfterShip is a post-purchase platform for online stores. It tracks shipments across 2,000+ carriers, sends branded delivery updates, and turns the tracking page into a place to recommend products. Returns run through a branded portal with exchanges, refunds and store credit, and Shipping compares rates and prints labels in bulk.

Plans are priced per product: Tracking, Returns and Shipping each have their own Essentials, Premium and Enterprise tiers, priced on monthly shipment or return volume. Tracking offers a 7-day free trial of its premium features, and each billing cycle lasts 30 days.

AfterShip pricing

There is a free plan and eight paid plans. Paid plans list a 7-day free trial. Paid plans start at $39/month.

Tracking Essentials
$49/mo
Tracking Premium
$99/mo
Tracking Enterprise
Custom
Returns Essentials
$205/mo
Returns Premium
$420/mo
Returns Enterprise
Custom
Shipping Essentials
$39/mo
Shipping Premium
$69/mo
Every AfterShip plan and what each includes

Who AfterShip suits

A good fit if

  • You want branded tracking and delivery updates across 2,000+ carriers.
  • You ship 500 or more orders a month and want labels at a flat $39 a month.
  • You need exchanges, store credit and warranty handling through a dedicated returns product.

Limits

  • AfterShip has a free plan on the Shopify App Store; paid vendor-site plans start at $39 a month.
  • Tracking and Returns charge overage at 1.3 times the plan's unit price when the included quota runs out.
  • Each product is priced separately, so Tracking, Returns and Shipping each need their own plan.
  • The pricing page advertises a free trial without stating its length; the Shopify listing puts it at 7 days for Tracking.

Source: AfterShip Tracking & Returns on the Shopify App Store, AfterShip Pricing: Tracking, Returns & Shipping Plans, AfterShip: Make every post-purchase moment count, How to Change, Upgrade, or Downgrade Your AfterShip Plan, Integrations | AfterShip Help Center, Carrier - FedEx Troubleshooting Tips and Enable and Customize Tracking Page Content in Multiple Languages.

Try AfterShip free

7-day free trial, paid from $39/month

What ShipStation does

ShipStation connects a Shopify store with every other sales channel and carrier in one dashboard for orders, shipping, inventory and returns. The listing names TikTok Shop, Amazon and Walmart among the channels, and discounted rates or a merchant's own rates with 200+ carriers including UPS, USPS, FedEx, DHL Express and GlobalPost. Automation rules batch, tag and route orders, and bulk label creation and batch printing cover one label or 500 at a time.

Prices start at $14.99 a month for the Starter plan and rise with monthly shipment volume, with 50 shipments a month at the listed price. Every plan includes a 30-day free trial, and Premium adds advanced inventory and warehouse management, custom analytics, auto-routing, Cubiscan and a dedicated account manager.

ShipStation pricing

There is a free plan and three paid plans. Paid plans list a 30-day free trial. Paid plans start at $14.99/month.

Starter
$14.99/mo
Standard
$29.99/mo
Premium
$349.99/mo
Every ShipStation plan and what each includes

Who ShipStation suits

A good fit if

  • You ship up to 100 orders a month and want the lowest entry price at $14.99 a month.
  • You sell on several marketplaces and want every order in one dashboard.
  • You need phone support from Standard or inventory management on Premium.

Limits

  • No free plan is listed; the cheapest entry is $14.99 a month.
  • Premium starts at $349.99 a month, and inventory management is only on Premium.
  • Prices rise with monthly shipment volume, so the listed price covers 50 shipments a month.
  • 18% of ratings are 1 star, per the listing's rating breakdown.

Source: ShipStation Orders & Inventory on the Shopify App Store, Pricing - ShipStation and Shipping Software for Ecommerce Fulfillment - ShipStation.

Try ShipStation free

30-day free trial, paid from $14.99/month

Pricing compared

Each tool's plans side by side, as monthly prices on monthly billing.

AfterShip plans

Tracking Essentials
Up to 1,000 shipments a month
$49
Tracking Premium
Up to 1,000 shipments a month
$99
Tracking Enterprise
Custom pricing
Custom
Returns Essentials
Up to 500 returns a month
$205
Returns Premium
Up to 500 returns a month
$420
Returns Enterprise
Custom pricing
Custom
Shipping Essentials Lowest price
Up to 1,000 shipments a month
$39
Shipping Premium
Starts at 2,000 shipments a month
$69
All AfterShip plans

ShipStation plans

Starter Lowest price
3 users; price varies with geography and monthly order volume.
$14.99
Standard
10 users; price varies with geography and monthly order volume.
$29.99
Premium
15 users; price varies with geography and monthly order volume.
$349.99
All ShipStation plans

Monthly prices from AfterShip Tracking and Returns on the Shopify App Store, AfterShip Pricing: Tracking, Returns and Shipping Plans, ShipStation Orders and Inventory on the Shopify App Store and ShipStation Pricing.

How they differ as you grow

What each upgrade adds

AfterShip
Tracking Essentials
Up to 1,000 shipments a month, branded tracking page, email and SMS delivery updates, exception and delay alerts, auto carrier detection, shipment dashboard and reports, AI Agent for setup and Q&A
$49
Tracking Premium
Up to 1,000 shipments a month, everything in Tracking Essentials, AI agent for exception handling, AI delivery date estimates, AI product recommendations, Order Edits for shoppers, custom tracking page and domain, full analytics, API and webhooks
$99
Tracking Enterprise
Volume above the picklist range priced with our team, everything in Tracking Premium, Multi-store and multi-brand, custom integrations, Custom API limits
Custom
Returns Essentials
Up to 500 returns a month, branded returns page, Exchanges, refunds and store credit, discounted auto return labels, eligibility and routing rules, return analytics, AI Agent for setup and Q&A
$205
Returns Premium
Up to 500 returns a month, everything in Returns Essentials, AI Agent RMA review, AI Exchanges to retain revenue, Order Edits for shoppers, warranty management, Shopify POS extension for in-store returns, advanced analytics and API
$420
Returns Enterprise
Everything in Returns Premium, Dedicated CSM and onboarding, SSO, security and SLAs, Multi-store and multi-brand, custom integrations and API limits, unlimited carriers and custom rates
Custom
Shipping Essentials
Up to 1,000 shipments a month, 100+ carriers with discounted rates, bulk label printing, smart carrier routing, Multi-channel order sync, combine and split orders, order management dashboard
$39
Shipping Premium
Starts at 2,000 shipments a month, everything in Shipping Essentials, connect your own carrier accounts, Label, rate and carrier APIs, APIs and webhooks, US address validation, WMS integrations
$69
Shipping Enterprise
Everything in Shipping Premium, unlimited carrier accounts, custom carrier integrations, SSO, Custom API limits
Custom
ShipStation
Starter
3 users, unlimited store connections, automated rate shopping, return labels, basic automations, reporting, email support, 30-day free trial
$14.99
Standard
10 users, unlimited automations, combine and split orders, bring your existing carrier accounts, returns and Exchanges, basic warehouse management, Shipping API, phone support, 30-day free trial
$29.99
Premium
15 users, inventory management, Auto-Split, cubiscan, Open Database Connectivity (ODBC), dedicated account manager, 30-day free trial
$349.99

How the bill grows with shipment volume

ShipStation charges by shipment volume inside each plan. Starter starts at $14.99 a month for 50 shipments, rises to $29.99 at 100 shipments, $39.99 at 500 and $79.99 at 1,000. AfterShip Shipping Essentials charges one flat $39 a month for up to 1,000 shipments. That puts the flip between 100 and 500 shipments a month: ShipStation costs less below it, AfterShip costs less above it. AfterShip Shipping Premium costs $69 a month and starts at 2,000 shipments a month.

Tracking is AfterShip's main job

AfterShip built its name on tracking: Tracking Essentials at $49 a month covers branded tracking pages, email and SMS updates and exception alerts across 2,000+ carriers, and Premium at $99 adds AI delivery dates and AI product recommendations. ShipStation also tracks orders, but its branded tracking page starts on Standard at $29.99 a month, and tracking sits beside labels, orders and inventory rather than leading the product. A store that buys mainly for delivery updates gets more tracking for the money from AfterShip.

Returns are a separate product on AfterShip

AfterShip sells returns as its own product: Returns Essentials costs $205 a month for up to 500 returns, with exchanges, refunds and store credit through a branded portal, and Premium at $420 adds warranty management. ShipStation folds returns into its shipping plans: return labels come with Starter at $14.99 a month, and the branded returns portal starts on Standard at $29.99. A store that needs returns handled without a second bill pays far less on ShipStation; a store that needs warranty handling and AI exchanges pays for AfterShip Returns.

One order hub against three priced products

ShipStation is one plan that covers orders, labels, tracking, returns and, on Premium at $349.99 a month, advanced inventory and warehouse management. Every plan connects unlimited stores. AfterShip prices Tracking, Returns and Shipping as separate products, each with its own Essentials, Premium and Enterprise tiers, so a store that wants tracking, returns and labels pays three bills. AfterShip Shipping Enterprise is custom priced; it is the ninth plan and sits outside the pricing block below.

Support, languages and the rating gap

AfterShip rates 4.6 stars from 1,514 reviews on the Shopify App Store, against 4.3 stars from 710 reviews for ShipStation, and 18% of ShipStation ratings are 1 star. AfterShip's support team answers by live chat and email, and its app works in 5 languages (English, German, French, Spanish, Italian). ShipStation gives email and chat on Starter, adds phone support on Standard, and a dedicated account manager on Premium, but lists 1 app language. Stores with shoppers in many languages get more from AfterShip; stores that want phone support get it sooner from ShipStation.

Source: AfterShip Pricing: Tracking, Returns and Shipping Plans, ShipStation Pricing, AfterShip Tracking and Returns on the Shopify App Store, ShipStation Orders and Inventory on the Shopify App Store and AfterShip Tracking and Returns reviews on the Shopify App Store.

Support and languages

DetailAfterShipShipStation
Live chatLive chat and email supportChat and email support on every plan; phone support on Standard and Premium
Top-plan supportNot listedDedicated account manager on Premium
App languages341: English
DeveloperAfterShip, Singapore, SingaporeShipStation, Austin, United States

Source: AfterShip Tracking & Returns on the Shopify App Store, AfterShip Pricing: Tracking, Returns & Shipping Plans, AfterShip: Make every post-purchase moment count, How to Change, Upgrade, or Downgrade Your AfterShip Plan, Integrations | AfterShip Help Center, Carrier - FedEx Troubleshooting Tips, Enable and Customize Tracking Page Content in Multiple Languages, ShipStation Orders & Inventory on the Shopify App Store, Pricing - ShipStation and Shipping Software for Ecommerce Fulfillment - ShipStation.

Common questions

Which is cheaper, AfterShip or ShipStation?

ShipStation is cheaper up to 100 shipments a month: Starter costs $29.99 a month at 100 shipments, against $39 for AfterShip Shipping Essentials. From 500 shipments, AfterShip is cheaper: Shipping Essentials stays $39 a month to 1,000 shipments, while ShipStation Starter costs $39.99 at 500 and $79.99 at 1,000.

Which has better tracking, AfterShip or ShipStation?

AfterShip. Tracking Essentials costs $49 a month and covers branded tracking pages and updates across 2,000+ carriers, with AI delivery dates on Premium at $99. ShipStation adds its branded tracking page on Standard at $29.99 a month.

Does ShipStation handle returns?

Yes. ShipStation includes return labels on the Starter plan at $14.99 a month, and its branded returns portal starts on Standard at $29.99 a month. AfterShip sells returns as a separate product from $205 a month.

Does AfterShip print shipping labels?

Yes. AfterShip Shipping Essentials costs $39 a month for up to 1,000 shipments, with rate comparison across 100+ carriers and bulk label printing. Shipping Premium at $69 a month starts at 2,000 shipments.

Which is better for selling on several marketplaces?

ShipStation. Every plan connects unlimited stores, and the listing names TikTok Shop, Amazon and Walmart among the channels it syncs with Shopify. AfterShip Shipping syncs orders across channels too, but multi-store support sits on its custom-priced Enterprise tiers.

Is there a free plan for either tool?

Yes — AfterShip lists a Free plan on the Shopify App Store (50 shipments a month for Tracking, 3 returns a month, 10 shipments a month for Shipping, no credit card required). ShipStation lists no free plan; it offers a 30-day free trial on every plan. AfterShip also offers a 7-day free trial of Tracking premium features.

Sources

Prices, plans, ratings and features on this page come from these sources. Found something out of date? Tell us.

Keep comparing

5

Browse
Categories