Joy Loyalty vs Smile.io: loyalty prices compared
Smile.io
Short answer
- Stores that take up to 250 orders a month and want to pay nothing
- J
Joy Joy's free Starter plan covers 250 monthly orders, while Smile's free plan stops at 200 and Smile charges $15 a month past that.
- Stores that want the lowest paid bill at 500 orders a month
- S
Smile.io Smile Essential is $15 a month at 500 orders, against Joy Essential at $29 for the same volume.
- Stores that take 501 to 800 orders a month
- J
Joy Joy Essential costs $44 a month at 600 orders and $74 at 800, while Smile Standard costs $79 for the same volumes.
- Stores that take more than 1,000 orders a month
- J
Joy Joy Advanced is $129 a month at 2,000 orders, against Smile Growth at $199 for the same volume.
- Stores that want a dedicated loyalty page for the lowest price
- S
Smile.io Smile Essential includes a dedicated loyalty page at $15 a month, against $29 for Joy Essential.
- Stores that want Shopify POS without paying
- S
Smile.io Smile's free plan works with Shopify POS, while Joy adds its POS loyalty extension on Advanced at $129 a month.
Pick Joy to 250 orders a month: the free plan covers 250 orders against Smile's 200. Smile costs less from 251 to 500 orders, at $15 a month against $29, and from 801 to 1,000 orders, at $79 against $89 to $104. Joy costs less from 501 to 800 orders and past 1,000 orders: Advanced is $129 at 2,000 orders against Smile Growth at $199. Both rate 4.9 stars, Joy from 1,784 reviews and Smile from 4,697.
Choose Joy if
- run up to 250 orders a month and want to pay nothing
- take 501 to 800 orders a month and want the lowest bill
Choose Smile.io if
- take 251 to 500 orders a month and want the lowest paid bill
- take 801 to 1,000 orders a month and want the lowest bill
Joy vs Smile.io at a glance
| Compare | Joy | Smile.io |
|---|---|---|
| EcomBeats score | Not rated yet | 7.2 out of 10 |
| Shopify App Store rating | 4.9 stars from 1,784 reviews | 4.9 stars from 4,697 reviews |
| Free plan limit | Up to 250 monthly orders | Up to 200 monthly orders |
| Cheapest paid plan | $29/mo (Essential) | $15/mo (Essential) |
| Cost at 500 orders a month | $29/mo (Essential) | $15/mo (Essential) |
| Cost at 600 orders a month | $44/mo (Essential plus $15 usage fee) | $79/mo (Standard) |
| Cost at 900 orders a month | $89/mo (Essential plus usage fees) | $79/mo (Standard) |
| Cost at 1,000 orders a month | $104/mo (Essential plus usage fees) | $79/mo (Standard) |
| Cost at 2,000 orders a month | $129/mo (Advanced) | $199/mo (Growth) |
| Cost at 7,000 orders a month | $499/mo (Ultimate) | $1,099/mo (Growth plus usage fees) |
| VIP tiers from | Advanced, $129/mo | Growth, $199/mo |
| Points expiry from | Essential, $29/mo | Growth, $199/mo |
| Dedicated loyalty page from | Essential, $29/mo | Essential, $15/mo |
| Shopify POS from | Advanced, $129/mo | Free plan |
| API access from | Ultimate, $499/mo | Smile Plus, $999/mo billed annually, not on the listing |
| Languages on the listing | 8 languages | 9 languages |
| Integrations named | 45+ tools | 30+ tools |
| Live chat with a support expert | Yes, 24/7, on every plan including free | Yes, on every plan including free |
| Free trial | 14 days (30 days on Ultimate) | 14 days |
| Built for Shopify badge | Yes | Yes |
| Links |
Source: Joy Loyalty Program Rewards on the Shopify App Store, Smile: Loyalty Program Rewards on the Shopify App Store, Joy pricing and Smile.io pricing. The EcomBeats score averages pricing, features, support and merchant reviews, each out of 10. How we rate
What Joy does
Joy is a loyalty and rewards app for Shopify stores. It runs points programs, VIP tiers and referrals, and lets shoppers earn points for purchases, sign-ups and social actions, then redeem them for discounts and other rewards on the widget, product pages, cart, checkout, customer accounts and Shopify POS.
Joy connects with Klaviyo, Judge.me, Loox, Gorgias, Recharge and 45+ integrations in all, and works with Shopify Flow, Shopify POS and customer accounts. Plans are priced by monthly orders, from a free Starter plan for up to 250 orders a month to Ultimate at $499 a month for up to 7,000 orders, with extra orders at $5 to $15 per 100.
Joy pricing
There is a free plan and three paid plans. Paid plans list a 14-day free trial. Paid plans start at $29/month.
- Starter
- $0
- Essential
- $29/mo
- Advanced
- $129/mo
- Ultimate
- $499/mo
Who Joy suits
A good fit if
- run up to 250 orders a month and want to pay nothing.
- take 501 to 800 orders a month and want the lowest bill.
- take more than 1,000 orders a month and want the lowest bill.
- want VIP tiers, Shopify POS and wallet passes for $129 a month.
- want points expiry rules from $29 a month.
Limits
- Essential costs $29 a month, nearly twice Smile Essential at $15 for the same 500-order cap.
- Past 800 orders, Essential usage fees push the bill above Smile Standard at $79 a month.
- VIP tiers and Shopify POS need Advanced at $129 a month; they are not on Starter or Essential.
- Orders above the plan quota add $15, $10 or $5 per 100 orders, so the monthly bill rises with order volume.
- The free Starter plan has no dedicated loyalty page or analytics reports.
Source: Joy Loyalty Program Rewards on the Shopify App Store, Pricing - Joy Loyalty, Rewards and Referrals for Shopify, Joy homepage, Pricing - Joy Help Center, Shopify loyalty integrations, 45+ native apps - Joy Loyalty and Smile: Loyalty Program Rewards on the Shopify App Store.
Try Joy free
Free plan: Free Starter plan covers up to 250 monthly orders with points, referrals and the loyalty widget., paid from $29/month
Smile.io
Plans and featuresWhat Smile.io does
Smile is a loyalty and rewards app for Shopify stores. It runs points programs, VIP tiers and referrals, and lets shoppers earn and redeem points online and in store with Shopify POS. Members see rewards on product pages, at checkout, on a loyalty page and inside customer accounts.
Smile connects with Klaviyo, Judge.me, Gorgias and more than 30 other tools, and works with Shopify Flow, Shopify POS and customer accounts. Plans are priced by monthly orders, from a free plan for up to 200 orders a month to Growth at $199 a month for up to 2,500 orders, with extra orders at $20 per 100.
Smile.io pricing
There is a free plan and three paid plans. Paid plans list a 14-day free trial. Paid plans start at $15/month.
- Free
- $0
- Essential
- $15/mo
- Standard
- $79/mo
- Growth
- $199/mo
Who Smile.io suits
A good fit if
- take 251 to 500 orders a month and want the lowest paid bill.
- take 801 to 1,000 orders a month and want the lowest bill.
- want a dedicated loyalty page for $15 a month.
- want Shopify POS on the free plan.
Limits
- The free plan covers only 200 monthly orders, 50 fewer than Joy's free plan.
- VIP tiers and points expiry need Growth at $199 a month.
- Essential has no usage fee for orders past 500, so a store at 600 orders pays Standard at $79 a month.
- Plans are priced by monthly orders, so the bill rises with order volume.
- Only 1 integration on Essential and 2 on Standard; unlimited integrations need Growth at $199 a month.
Source: Smile: Loyalty Program Rewards on the Shopify App Store, Smile.io Pricing and Plans and Smile homepage.
Try Smile.io free
Free plan: Free plan covers up to 200 monthly orders with points, referrals and discount rewards., paid from $15/month
Pricing compared
Each tool's plans side by side, as monthly prices on monthly billing.
Joy plans
Smile.io plans
Monthly prices from Joy Loyalty Program Rewards on the Shopify App Store, Joy pricing, Smile: Loyalty Program Rewards on the Shopify App Store and Smile.io pricing.
How they differ as you grow
What each upgrade adds
How the bill grows with orders
Both tools price by monthly orders, and the cheaper one flips four times as volume grows. To 250 orders a month, Joy costs nothing on its free Starter plan while Smile charges $15 a month past 200 orders. From 251 to 500 orders, Smile Essential is $15 a month against Joy Essential at $29. From 501 to 800 orders, Joy costs less: Essential is $44 a month at 600 orders and $74 at 800, against Smile Standard at $79, because Smile Essential lists no usage fee and the store moves to Standard past 500 orders. From 801 to 1,000 orders, Smile costs less again at $79 against Joy Essential at $89 to $104. Past 1,000 orders, Joy costs less: Advanced is $129 a month at 2,000 orders against Smile Growth at $199, and Ultimate is $499 at 7,000 orders against Smile Growth at $1,099 with usage fees.
VIP tiers, points expiry and POS sit on different plans
Joy puts VIP tiers, Shopify POS and wallet passes on Advanced at $129 a month, and points expiry rules start lower, on Essential at $29 a month. Smile puts VIP tiers and points expiry together on Growth at $199 a month, and adds its Loyalty Hub and redeem points at checkout there too. The one exception is Shopify POS: Smile works with POS on every plan, including the free plan, while Joy adds its POS loyalty extension on Advanced. A store that wants VIP tiers for the lowest price pays $129 on Joy against $199 on Smile; a store that wants POS without paying picks Smile.
The free plans are not equal
Joy's free Starter plan covers 250 monthly orders with points, referrals and the loyalty widget, plus 24/7 live chat support. Smile's free plan covers 200 monthly orders with points, rewards and referrals, 15+ ways to earn and redeem, discount and free shipping rewards, full branding customization and multi-language support in 20+ languages, and works with Shopify POS. Joy's free plan has no dedicated loyalty page or analytics reports; those start on Essential at $29 a month. A store that stays under 200 orders a month pays nothing on either tool.
Languages and support
Smile's listing names 9 languages and Joy's names 8. Smile's free plan includes multi-language support in 20+ languages, while Joy's widget ships in 8 languages. Both tools include live chat on every plan, including the free plan: Joy lists 24/7 live chat support on Starter, and Smile lists live chat with a loyalty expert. Joy adds a dedicated account manager on Ultimate at $499 a month, and Smile adds priority support on its Plus plan. A store that needs the program in more than one language has 9 options on Smile's listing against 8 on Joy's.
Integrations and the tools each names
Joy names 45+ integrations in all, with 30+ on Essential at $29 a month, including Klaviyo, Recharge, Judge.me, Loox and Omnisend, plus Shopify Flow automation with 22+ triggers. Unlimited integrations and REST API access arrive on Ultimate at $499 a month. Smile names 30+ tools, with 1 integration on Essential at $15 a month, 2 on Standard at $79, and unlimited integrations on Growth at $199. Both tools list Klaviyo, Judge.me, Loox, Recharge, Shopify POS and Shopify Flow. Smile also names Gorgias and Mailchimp, while Joy also names Omnisend.
Plans only on each tool's own pricing page
Smile's own pricing page lists two plans the App Store listing does not show: Smile Plus at $999 a month billed annually, with 7,500 monthly orders and API access, and Enterprise at a custom price with unlimited monthly orders. Joy's own pricing page names a custom plan for stores past 17,000 orders a month, with no listed price. The pricing blocks on this page follow the App Store listings, which show four plans for each tool, because the listing is the source a Shopify store is billed through.
Source: Joy Loyalty Program Rewards on the Shopify App Store, Joy pricing, Smile: Loyalty Program Rewards on the Shopify App Store and Smile.io pricing.
Support and languages
| Detail | Joy | Smile.io |
|---|---|---|
| Live chat | 24/7 live chat on every plan | Live chat with a loyalty expert on every plan |
| Top-plan support | Dedicated Account Manager, priority support and on-demand development on Ultimate | Priority support from Smile Plus |
| App languages | Not listed | 9: English, French, Japanese, German, Italian, Chinese (Simplified), Portuguese (Brazil), Dutch, Spanish |
| Developer | Joy Loyalty Program & Rewards | Smile.io, Waterloo, ON, Canada |
Source: Joy Loyalty Program Rewards on the Shopify App Store, Pricing - Joy Loyalty, Rewards and Referrals for Shopify, Joy homepage, Pricing - Joy Help Center, Shopify loyalty integrations, 45+ native apps - Joy Loyalty, Smile: Loyalty Program Rewards on the Shopify App Store, Smile.io Pricing and Plans and Smile homepage.
Common questions
Which is cheaper, Joy or Smile.io?
It flips with order volume. Joy costs nothing to 250 orders a month, Smile costs less from 251 to 500 orders at $15 a month against $29, Joy costs less from 501 to 800 orders, Smile costs less again from 801 to 1,000 orders at $79 a month, and Joy costs less past 1,000 orders.
Which free plan covers more orders?
Joy's free Starter plan covers 250 monthly orders, 50 more than Smile's free plan at 200. Both free plans include points, referrals and live chat support.
Which tool has VIP tiers for less?
Joy. VIP tiers start on Advanced at $129 a month, against Growth at $199 a month for Smile. Joy also starts points expiry rules lower, on Essential at $29 a month, while Smile puts points expiry on Growth at $199.
Do both tools work with Shopify POS?
Yes. Smile works with Shopify POS on every plan, including the free plan. Joy adds its POS loyalty extension on Advanced at $129 a month, so in-store shoppers earn and redeem points at the counter from that plan.
Does Smile.io have a plan above Growth?
Yes, on its own pricing page. Smile Plus costs $999 a month billed annually, with 7,500 monthly orders and API access, and Enterprise has a custom price with unlimited monthly orders. The App Store listing shows four plans, up to Growth at $199 a month.
Which tool has the longer free trial?
Joy, on its top plan. Ultimate has a 30-day free trial, while Essential and Advanced have 14 days, and Smile has a 14-day free trial on its paid plans.