EcomBeatsSearch tools and comparisonsCtrl KSubmit a tool

Smile.io vs LoyaltyLion: loyalty program prices compared

Short answer

Stores that take up to 400 orders a month and want to pay nothing

LoyaltyLion LoyaltyLion's free plan covers 400 monthly orders, twice Smile's 200, with points, discount rewards and 7 pre-written languages.

Stores that want the lowest paid bill

Smile.io Smile Essential is $15 a month at 500 orders, against LoyaltyLion Classic at $199 a month for the same volume.

Stores that want VIP tiers with a stated order allowance

Smile.io Smile Growth is $199 a month and includes 2,500 monthly orders with VIP tiers, while LoyaltyLion's listing states no included order limit for Classic at the same $199.

Stores that want live chat support without paying

Smile.io Smile includes live chat with a loyalty expert on every plan, including the free plan, while LoyaltyLion's listing names FAQ and tutorial resources.

Stores that want the loyalty page and Klaviyo flows built for them

LoyaltyLion LoyaltyLion Classic at $199 a month includes a loyalty page design worth $1,500 and Klaviyo loyalty flows built for the store.

Pick LoyaltyLion if the store takes up to 400 orders a month: the free plan covers 400 orders, twice Smile's 200. Past 400 orders, pick Smile: Essential is $15 a month at 500 orders against Classic at $199, and Standard is $79 at 1,000 orders while LoyaltyLion quotes a custom price above 500. Both rate above 4.7 stars, Smile at 4.9 from 4,685 reviews and LoyaltyLion at 4.7 from 552.

Choose Smile.io if

  • want the lowest paid bill at 500 orders a month
  • want VIP tiers with a stated order allowance of 2,500 orders a month
Read the full Smile.io details

Choose LoyaltyLion if

  • run up to 400 orders a month and want to pay nothing
  • want a loyalty page designed for the store and Klaviyo flows built for the store
Read the full LoyaltyLion details

Smile.io vs LoyaltyLion at a glance

CompareSmile.ioLoyaltyLion
EcomBeats score7.2 out of 10Not rated yet
Shopify App Store rating4.9 stars from 4,685 reviews4.7 stars from 552 reviews
Free plan limitUp to 200 monthly ordersUp to 400 monthly orders
Cheapest paid plan$15/mo (Essential)$199/mo (Classic)
Cost at 500 orders a month$15/mo (Essential)$199/mo (Classic)
Cost at 1,000 orders a month$79/mo (Standard)No listed price; custom quote for Advanced or Plus
VIP tiers with a stated order allowanceGrowth, $199/mo, 2,500 orders includedClassic, $199/mo, no included limit stated
Points expiryGrowth, $199/moNot listed on the listing or pricing page
Loyalty page on the cheapest paid planDedicated loyalty page on Essential, $15/moLoyalty page design worth $1,500 on Classic, $199/mo
Languages on the listing9 languagesEnglish
Integrations named30+ tools50+ apps
Unlimited integrations fromGrowth, $199/moClassic, $199/mo
Live chat with a support expertYes, on every plan including freeNot listed on the listing or pricing page
Free trial14 days (Essential, Standard, Growth)14 days (Classic)
Built for Shopify badgeYesNo
Links

Source: Smile: Loyalty Program Rewards on the Shopify App Store, LoyaltyLion on the Shopify App Store, LoyaltyLion pricing and Smile.io pricing. The EcomBeats score averages pricing, features, support and merchant reviews, each out of 10. How we rate

What Smile.io does

Smile is a loyalty and rewards app for Shopify stores. It runs points programs, VIP tiers and referrals, and lets shoppers earn and redeem points online and in store with Shopify POS. Members see rewards on product pages, at checkout, on a loyalty page and inside customer accounts.

Smile connects with Klaviyo, Judge.me, Gorgias and more than 30 other tools, and works with Shopify Flow, Shopify POS and customer accounts. Plans are priced by monthly orders, from a free plan for up to 200 orders a month to Growth at $199 a month for up to 2,500 orders, with extra orders at $20 per 100.

Smile.io pricing

There is a free plan and three paid plans. Paid plans list a 14-day free trial. Paid plans start at $15/month.

Free
$0
Essential
$15/mo
Standard
$79/mo
Growth
$199/mo
Every Smile.io plan and what each includes

Who Smile.io suits

A good fit if

  • want the lowest paid bill at 500 orders a month.
  • want VIP tiers with a stated order allowance of 2,500 orders a month.
  • want live chat support on the free plan.
  • want the program in more than one language, with 9 languages on the listing.

Limits

  • VIP tiers and points expiry need Growth at $199 a month.
  • The free plan covers only 200 monthly orders, half of LoyaltyLion's free limit.
  • Plans are priced by monthly orders, so the bill rises with order volume.
  • Only 1 integration on Essential and 2 on Standard; unlimited integrations need Growth at $199 a month.

Source: Smile: Loyalty Program Rewards on the Shopify App Store, Smile.io Pricing and Plans and Smile homepage.

Try Smile.io free

Free plan: Free plan covers up to 200 monthly orders with points, referrals and discount rewards., paid from $15/month

What LoyaltyLion does

LoyaltyLion is a loyalty program for Shopify stores that runs points, rewards, referrals and VIP tiers. Shoppers earn points for on-site activities and redeem them for pound and percentage discount rewards, while stores track loyalty-attributed revenue and segment customers with loyalty analytics.

The free plan covers up to 400 monthly orders and includes branding and customization options, real-time on-site notifications and a choice of 7 pre-written languages. The Classic plan at $199 a month adds a loyalty page design worth $1,500, customizable rules and rewards, unlimited integrations, VIP loyalty tiers, POS locations and Klaviyo loyalty flows built for the store.

LoyaltyLion pricing

There is a free plan and one paid plan. Paid plans list a 14-day free trial. Paid plans start at $199/month.

Free
$0
Classic
$199/mo
Every LoyaltyLion plan and what each includes

Who LoyaltyLion suits

A good fit if

  • run up to 400 orders a month and want to pay nothing.
  • want a loyalty page designed for the store and Klaviyo flows built for the store.
  • want unlimited integrations on the first paid plan.
  • want VIP tiers listed on a $199 a month plan.

Limits

  • The only paid plan with a listed price is Classic at $199 a month; stores over 500 orders a month must ask for a custom quote.
  • No paid plan sits between free and $199 a month.
  • The listing names English as its only language.
  • The listing states no included monthly order limit for Classic.

Source: LoyaltyLion Loyalty & Rewards on the Shopify App Store, LoyaltyLion pricing and LoyaltyLion | Customer loyalty platform.

Try LoyaltyLion free

Free plan: Free plan for stores with up to 400 monthly orders., paid from $199/month

Pricing compared

Each tool's plans side by side, as monthly prices on monthly billing.

Smile.io plans

Free
Up to 200 monthly orders.
$0
Essential Lowest price
Up to 500 monthly orders.
$15
Standard
Up to 1,000 monthly orders.
$79
Growth
Includes 2,500 monthly orders, then $20 per additional 100 orders.
$199
All Smile.io plans

LoyaltyLion plans

Free
400 monthly orders.
$0
Classic Lowest price
14-day free trial. Stores with more than 500 orders a month are quoted for Advanced or Plus plans.
$199
All LoyaltyLion plans

Monthly prices from Smile: Loyalty Program Rewards on the Shopify App Store, Smile.io pricing, LoyaltyLion on the Shopify App Store and LoyaltyLion pricing.

How they differ as you grow

What each upgrade adds

Smile.io
Essential
Up to 500 monthly orders, dedicated loyalty page, free product rewards, nudges (on-site reminders), analytics & reporting, trigger rewards with Shopify Flow, 1 integration (e.g. Klaviyo)
$15
Standard
Up to 1,000 monthly orders, bonus events (e.g. 2x points weekend), embed points on product pages, promote points on order thank you page, subscription & gift card rewards, loyalty segments, ROI and CLV insights, 2 integrations (e.g. Klaviyo, Judge.me)
$79
Growth
Includes 2,500 monthly orders, then $20 per additional 100 orders, Loyalty Hub (for signed-in members), redeem at checkout (Shopify Plus), VIP tiers & Points expiry, performance benchmarks, 25+ pre-built loyalty reports, unlimited integrations
$199
Smile Plus
7,500 monthly orders, 30+ specialized reports, unlimited integrations, migration and launch plan, quarterly program monitoring, priority support, API access
$999
Smile Enterprise
Unlimited monthly orders, custom reports, unlimited integrations, advanced security, 99.9% historical uptime, Custom API rate limits, data warehouse sync
Custom
LoyaltyLion
Classic
Free loyalty page design worth $1,500, customizable rules and rewards, unlimited integrations, 5-star onboarding support, VIP loyalty tiers, POS locations, loyalty attributed revenue reporting, klaviyo loyalty flows built for you
$199

How the bill grows with orders

Both tools price by monthly orders, and the cheaper one flips as volume grows. Up to 400 orders a month, LoyaltyLion costs nothing on its free plan while Smile charges $15 a month past 200 orders. At 500 orders, Smile Essential is $15 a month and LoyaltyLion Classic is $199 a month. At 1,000 orders, Smile Standard is $79 a month; LoyaltyLion has no listed price at that volume and sends stores over 500 orders to a custom quote for Advanced or Plus. At 2,500 orders, Smile Growth is $199 a month with $20 per 100 orders above the limit.

VIP tiers, and a disagreement between LoyaltyLion's own pages

VIP tiers sit on the $199 plan on both tools, but LoyaltyLion's own pages disagree about which plan that is. Its Shopify listing includes VIP loyalty tiers on Classic at $199 a month. Its pricing page puts VIP tiers on Advanced, which has no listed price. The listing is the canonical source for a Shopify app, so this page follows the listing: VIP tiers come with Classic at $199 a month. Smile puts VIP tiers on Growth at $199 a month, with 2,500 monthly orders included.

The free plans are not equal

LoyaltyLion's free plan covers 400 monthly orders, twice Smile's 200, and includes branding and customization, loyalty analytics and customer segments, real-time on-site notifications and a choice of 7 pre-written languages. Smile's free plan covers 200 monthly orders with points, rewards and referrals, 15+ ways to earn and redeem, discount and free shipping rewards, full branding customization and multi-language support in 20+ languages, and works with Shopify POS. A store that stays under 200 orders a month pays nothing on either tool.

Languages and support

Smile lists 9 languages on its listing and includes live chat with a loyalty expert on every plan, including the free plan. LoyaltyLion's listing names English as its only language, while its free plan lets stores select from 7 pre-written languages. LoyaltyLion's listing names FAQ and tutorial resources, and Classic adds dedicated onboarding support. A store that needs the program in more than one language has 9 options on Smile's listing against English on LoyaltyLion's.

Integrations and the tools each names

LoyaltyLion names more than 50 apps, with Checkout, Customer accounts, Shopify POS, Shopify Flow, Attentive, Gorgias, Klaviyo, ReCharge, Tapcart and Yotpo on its listing, and Classic includes unlimited integrations. Smile names more than 30 tools, with Checkout, Customer accounts, Shopify POS, Shopify Flow, Shopify Admin, Gorgias, Judge.me, Klaviyo, Loox, Mailchimp and Recharge, and limits integrations to 1 on Essential and 2 on Standard, with unlimited integrations only on Growth at $199 a month. Both tools list Klaviyo, Gorgias and Shopify POS.

Source: Smile: Loyalty Program Rewards on the Shopify App Store, LoyaltyLion on the Shopify App Store, LoyaltyLion pricing and Smile.io pricing.

Support and languages

DetailSmile.ioLoyaltyLion
Live chatLive chat with a loyalty expert on every planNot listed
Top-plan supportPriority support from Smile PlusNot listed
App languages9: English, French, Japanese, German, Italian, Chinese (Simplified), Portuguese (Brazil), Dutch, Spanish1: English
DeveloperSmile.io, Waterloo, ON, CanadaLoyaltyLion, London, United Kingdom

Source: Smile: Loyalty Program Rewards on the Shopify App Store, Smile.io Pricing and Plans, Smile homepage, LoyaltyLion Loyalty & Rewards on the Shopify App Store and LoyaltyLion | Customer loyalty platform.

Common questions

Which is cheaper, Smile.io or LoyaltyLion?

LoyaltyLion is cheaper up to 400 orders a month, and Smile is cheaper above that. LoyaltyLion's free plan covers 400 orders while Smile's free plan stops at 200. At 500 orders, Smile Essential is $15 a month against LoyaltyLion Classic at $199. At 1,000 orders, Smile Standard is $79 a month while LoyaltyLion has no listed price and quotes a custom price.

Does LoyaltyLion Classic include VIP tiers?

Yes, according to its Shopify listing, which includes VIP loyalty tiers on Classic at $199 a month. Its pricing page puts VIP tiers on Advanced instead. The listing is the canonical source for a Shopify app, so this page follows the listing.

Which free plan covers more orders?

LoyaltyLion's free plan covers 400 monthly orders, twice Smile's 200. Smile's free plan includes points, rewards and referrals, 15+ ways to earn and redeem, and multi-language support in 20+ languages. LoyaltyLion's free plan includes points, discount rewards, loyalty analytics and a choice of 7 pre-written languages.

Do Smile.io and LoyaltyLion work with Shopify POS?

Yes, both list Shopify POS in the Works with section of their listings. Smile's free plan works with Shopify POS, and LoyaltyLion Classic includes POS locations.

Which tool has better support?

Smile includes live chat with a loyalty expert on every plan, including the free plan. LoyaltyLion's listing names FAQ and tutorial resources, and Classic adds dedicated onboarding support.

Do both tools integrate with Klaviyo?

Yes. Smile lists Klaviyo among its integrations, with 1 integration on Essential, 2 on Standard and unlimited integrations on Growth. LoyaltyLion lists Klaviyo too, with unlimited integrations on Classic and Klaviyo loyalty flows built for the store.

Sources

Prices, plans, ratings and features on this page come from these sources. Found something out of date? Tell us.

Keep comparing

4

Browse
Categories