EcomBeatsSearch tools and comparisonsCtrl KSubmit a tool

Smile.io vs Yotpo: loyalty and review prices compared

Short answer

Stores that want points, referrals and VIP tiers in one app

Smile.io Smile Essential costs $15 a month up to 500 orders and includes points and referrals, while Yotpo Loyalty is a separate product with paid tiers from $199 a month.

Stores with 500 monthly orders

Smile.io Smile Essential costs $15 a month at 500 orders, while Yotpo Starter costs $89 a month at the same volume.

Stores that want a free trial before paying

Smile.io Smile paid plans include a 14-day free trial, while Yotpo lists no trial length on its listing or pricing page.

Stores that sell in more than one language

Smile.io Smile lists 9 app languages, while Yotpo lists English only.

Stores that want product reviews with AI summaries

Yotpo Yotpo Pro adds AI summaries at $119 a month at 50 orders, while Smile runs no product reviews.

Stores that want reviews syndicated to the most channels

Yotpo Yotpo syndicates reviews to Google Shopping, Instagram, TikTok and retail partners, while Smile has no review syndication.

Pick Smile.io for loyalty: Essential costs $15 a month up to 500 orders and includes points and referrals, while Yotpo sells loyalty as a separate product with paid tiers from $199 a month. Pick Yotpo for reviews: Starter costs $15 a month at 50 orders and Pro adds AI summaries at $119 a month, with syndication to Google Shopping, Instagram, TikTok and retail partners. Smile rates 4.9 stars against 4.8 for Yotpo, and both offer a free plan.

Choose Smile.io if

  • want points, VIP tiers and referrals in one app for $15 a month at 500 orders
  • run up to 200 orders a month and want a free loyalty plan
Read the full Smile.io details

Choose Yotpo if

  • want photo and video reviews with AI summaries on Pro for $119 a month at 50 orders
  • want reviews syndicated to Google Shopping, Instagram, TikTok and retail partners
Read the full Yotpo details

Smile.io vs Yotpo at a glance

CompareSmile.ioYotpo
EcomBeats score7.2 out of 106.6 out of 10
Shopify App Store rating4.9 stars from 4,685 reviews4.8 stars from 4,623 reviews
Cheapest paid plan$15/mo (Essential, up to 500 orders)$15/mo (Starter, at 50 orders)
Free planFree plan, up to 200 monthly ordersFree plan, up to 50 monthly orders
Free trial on paid plans14-day free trialNo trial length listed
Price at 500 monthly ordersEssential $15/moStarter $89/mo
Loyalty programPoints, VIP tiers and referrals in one appSeparate product, paid tiers from $199/mo
Product reviewsNot offeredPhoto and video reviews, AI summaries on Pro
Review syndicationNot offeredGoogle Shopping, Instagram, TikTok and retail partners
VIP tiersGrowth $199/moNot in the reviews app; separate loyalty product
In-store earning with Shopify POSEarn and redeem points in store on any planNot offered
Live chat supportLive chat with a loyalty expert on every plan, including freeAI chat on Free and Starter, email support on Pro
App languages9 languagesEnglish
Links

Source: Smile: Loyalty Program Rewards on the Shopify App Store, Yotpo Product Reviews App on the Shopify App Store, Smile.io pricing and Yotpo pricing. The EcomBeats score averages pricing, features, support and merchant reviews, each out of 10. How we rate

What Smile.io does

Smile is a loyalty and rewards app for Shopify stores. It runs points programs, VIP tiers and referrals, and lets shoppers earn and redeem points online and in store with Shopify POS. Members see rewards on product pages, at checkout, on a loyalty page and inside customer accounts.

Smile connects with Klaviyo, Judge.me, Gorgias and more than 30 other tools, and works with Shopify Flow, Shopify POS and customer accounts. Plans are priced by monthly orders, from a free plan for up to 200 orders a month to Growth at $199 a month for up to 2,500 orders, with extra orders at $20 per 100.

Smile.io pricing

There is a free plan and three paid plans. Paid plans list a 14-day free trial. Paid plans start at $15/month.

Free
$0
Essential
$15/mo
Standard
$79/mo
Growth
$199/mo
Every Smile.io plan and what each includes

Who Smile.io suits

A good fit if

  • want points, VIP tiers and referrals in one app for $15 a month at 500 orders.
  • run up to 200 orders a month and want a free loyalty plan.
  • want a 14-day free trial before paying.
  • sell in more than one language and need 9 app languages.
  • run Shopify POS and want in-store shoppers to earn and redeem points.

Limits

  • Plans are priced by monthly orders, so a store over 1,000 orders a month pays at least $199 a month for Growth.
  • VIP tiers and points expiry need Growth at $199 a month; they are not on the Free, Essential or Standard plans.
  • API access is not on the four App Store plans.
  • Smile runs no product reviews, so a store that wants reviews needs a second app.
  • Growth charges $20 per 100 additional orders past 2,500 monthly orders.

Source: Smile: Loyalty Program Rewards on the Shopify App Store, Smile.io Pricing and Plans and Smile homepage.

Try Smile.io free

Free plan: Free plan covers up to 200 monthly orders with points, referrals and discount rewards., paid from $15/month

What Yotpo does

Yotpo is a product reviews app for Shopify stores. It collects photo and video reviews through automatic email and SMS requests, then displays them in widgets on product pages, with AI summaries and smart sorting on Pro. The app also runs site reviews, questions and answers.

Reviews syndicate to Google Shopping, Google Seller Ratings, Instagram, TikTok and retail partners, and the app adds SEO pages for reviews. Yotpo lists more than 35,000 brands using the platform.

Yotpo pricing

There is a free plan and four paid plans. Paid plans start at $15/month.

Free
$0
Starter
$15/mo
Pro
$119/mo
Premium
Custom
Enterprise
Custom
Every Yotpo plan and what each includes

Who Yotpo suits

A good fit if

  • want photo and video reviews with AI summaries on Pro for $119 a month at 50 orders.
  • want reviews syndicated to Google Shopping, Instagram, TikTok and retail partners.
  • want reviews only, without loyalty tools in the same app.
  • want SEO pages for reviews and site reviews with questions and answers.

Limits

  • Prices rise with monthly order volume: Starter costs $15 a month at 50 orders and $89 at 500 orders.
  • Premium and Enterprise have no listed price; both need a custom quote.
  • No free trial length is listed on the App Store listing or the pricing page.
  • Live support is AI chat only on Free and Starter; technical support by email is listed on Pro.
  • Loyalty and referrals are a separate Yotpo product, with paid tiers from $199 a month.

Source: Yotpo: Product Reviews App on the Shopify App Store, Yotpo pricing, Yotpo Reviews and UGC platform and Yotpo: eCommerce Retention Marketing Platform.

Try Yotpo free

Free plan: Free plan for up to 50 monthly orders., paid from $15/month

Pricing compared

Each tool's plans side by side, as monthly prices on monthly billing.

Smile.io plans

Free
Up to 200 monthly orders.
$0
Essential Lowest price
Up to 500 monthly orders.
$15
Standard
Up to 1,000 monthly orders.
$79
Growth
Includes 2,500 monthly orders, then $20 per additional 100 orders.
$199
All Smile.io plans

Yotpo plans

Free
Up to 50 monthly orders.
$0
Starter Lowest price
Price changes based on order volume; $15 a month at 50 monthly orders, or $144 a year.
$15
Pro
Price changes based on order volume; $119 a month at 50 monthly orders, or $1,068 a year.
$119
Premium
Custom
Enterprise
Custom
All Yotpo plans

Monthly prices from Smile: Loyalty Program Rewards on the Shopify App Store, Smile.io pricing, Yotpo Product Reviews App on the Shopify App Store and Yotpo pricing.

How they differ as you grow

What each upgrade adds

Smile.io
Essential
Up to 500 monthly orders, dedicated loyalty page, free product rewards, nudges (on-site reminders), analytics & reporting, trigger rewards with Shopify Flow, 1 integration (e.g. Klaviyo)
$15
Standard
Up to 1,000 monthly orders, bonus events (e.g. 2x points weekend), embed points on product pages, promote points on order thank you page, subscription & gift card rewards, loyalty segments, ROI and CLV insights, 2 integrations (e.g. Klaviyo, Judge.me)
$79
Growth
Includes 2,500 monthly orders, then $20 per additional 100 orders, Loyalty Hub (for signed-in members), redeem at checkout (Shopify Plus), VIP tiers & Points expiry, performance benchmarks, 25+ pre-built loyalty reports, unlimited integrations
$199
Smile Plus
7,500 monthly orders, 30+ specialized reports, unlimited integrations, migration and launch plan, quarterly program monitoring, priority support, API access
$999
Smile Enterprise
Unlimited monthly orders, custom reports, unlimited integrations, advanced security, 99.9% historical uptime, Custom API rate limits, data warehouse sync
Custom
Yotpo
Starter
Pricing changes based on order volume, collect photos and video, Google Rich Snippets, Google Shopping Ads, reviews carousel, AI chat support
$15
Pro
Pricing changes based on order volume, Google Seller Rating, custom questions, AI reviews summary, smart sorting, AI chat support, technical support via email
$119
Premium
Reviews AI summary, roles and permissions, widgets and email translations, retail syndication, dedicated customer success manager
Custom
Enterprise
Custom API setup, Omni-channel reviews collection, syndicate across brands and markets, enterprise customer success manager
Custom

Different jobs: loyalty against reviews

Smile runs a loyalty program: points, VIP tiers and referrals for Shopify stores, with in-store earning through Shopify POS. Yotpo collects photo and video reviews, adds AI summaries and smart sorting on Pro, and syndicates reviews to Google Shopping, Instagram, TikTok and retail partners. A store that wants both jobs buys two products, since Yotpo sells loyalty as a separate product with paid tiers from $199 a month, and Smile runs no reviews. Pick on the job that matters more: loyalty points and repeat purchases, or review content and social proof.

How the bill grows with monthly orders

Both tools price by monthly orders. At 50 orders the cheapest paid plan costs $15 a month on both: Smile Essential and Yotpo Starter. Smile Essential stays $15 a month up to 500 orders, while Yotpo Starter rises to $89 a month at 500 orders. Smile Standard costs $79 a month up to 1,000 orders, and Growth costs $199 a month for 2,500 orders plus $20 per 100 additional orders. The free plans differ too: Smile covers up to 200 monthly orders free, Yotpo covers up to 50.

Free plan and free trial

Smile gives the longer free runway: its free plan covers up to 200 monthly orders with points, referrals and discount rewards, against 50 orders on Yotpo Free. Smile paid plans also include a 14-day free trial, so a store can try Essential, Standard or Growth before paying. Yotpo lists no trial length on its listing or pricing page, so a store moving to Starter or Pro pays from the first month.

Features only one tool has

Smile keeps VIP tiers, points expiry, the Loyalty Hub for signed-in members and 25+ pre-built loyalty reports on Growth at $199 a month. Yotpo Pro adds AI summaries and smart sorting at $119 a month at 50 orders, while syndication across domains and to retail partners sits on higher tiers. Smile also runs in-store earning through Shopify POS on any plan, and Yotpo adds SEO pages for reviews plus site reviews with questions and answers. Neither tool covers the other's job, so a store that wants VIP tiers and AI review summaries pays for both.

Support and languages

Smile includes live chat with a loyalty expert on every plan, including the free plan, and lists 9 app languages. Yotpo gives AI chat on Free and Starter, with technical support by email on Pro, and lists English only. A store that sells in more than one language, or wants a person on chat from the free plan, gets more from Smile.

Source: Smile: Loyalty Program Rewards on the Shopify App Store, Smile.io pricing, Yotpo Product Reviews App on the Shopify App Store and Yotpo pricing.

Support and languages

DetailSmile.ioYotpo
Live chatLive chat with a loyalty expert on every planAI chat support on every plan
Top-plan supportPriority support from Smile PlusTechnical support via email on Pro
App languages9: English, French, Japanese, German, Italian, Chinese (Simplified), Portuguese (Brazil), Dutch, Spanish1: English
DeveloperSmile.io, Waterloo, ON, CanadaYotpo, New York, NY, United States

Source: Smile: Loyalty Program Rewards on the Shopify App Store, Smile.io Pricing and Plans, Smile homepage, Yotpo: Product Reviews App on the Shopify App Store, Yotpo pricing, Yotpo Reviews and UGC platform and Yotpo: eCommerce Retention Marketing Platform.

Common questions

Which is cheaper, Smile.io or Yotpo?

Both cost the same at low volume: the cheapest paid plan is $15 a month on each at 50 orders. At 500 orders Smile Essential still costs $15 a month, while Yotpo Starter costs $89 a month.

Does Smile.io collect product reviews?

No. Smile runs points, VIP tiers and referrals for Shopify stores. A store that wants photo and video reviews needs a second app such as Yotpo.

Does Yotpo offer a loyalty program?

Yes, as a separate product. Yotpo Loyalty and Referrals has a free plan with paid tiers from $199 a month, while the reviews app compared here covers reviews only.

Which tool has the higher rating?

Smile, at 4.9 stars from 4,685 Shopify App Store reviews, against 4.8 stars from 4,623 reviews for Yotpo.

Which free plan covers more orders?

Smile. Its free plan covers up to 200 monthly orders with points, referrals and discount rewards, while Yotpo Free covers up to 50 monthly orders.

Which tool offers a free trial?

Smile. Its paid plans include a 14-day free trial. Yotpo lists no trial length on its App Store listing or pricing page.

Sources

Prices, plans, ratings and features on this page come from these sources. Found something out of date? Tell us.

Keep comparing

11

Browse
Categories