EcomBeatsSearch tools and comparisonsCtrl KSubmit a tool

PayWhirl vs Recharge: subscription prices compared

Short answer

Stores starting subscriptions on a small budget

PayWhirl PayWhirl starts free and paid plans begin at $9 a month, while Recharge Starter costs $149 a month.

Stores that want bundles, A/B testing and an AI agent

Recharge Recharge Scale adds bundles, tiered discounts, A/B testing and the Remi AI agent for $499 a month.

Stores that sell on BigCommerce as well as Shopify

Recharge Recharge runs on Shopify and BigCommerce, while PayWhirl runs on Shopify only, so a store on 2 platforms has 1 tool to pick.

Stores moving from Recharge that want free migration help

PayWhirl PayWhirl offers migration help from Recharge at no separate fee, while Recharge puts migration support on Scale at $499 a month.

Pick PayWhirl to start subscriptions from free: paid plans begin at $9 a month, workflow automation costs $29 a month, and migration help from Recharge costs nothing extra. Pick Recharge for a larger program: Starter is $149 a month with a 60-day trial, and Scale at $499 a month adds bundles, tiered discounts, A/B testing and the Remi AI agent. Recharge also runs on BigCommerce, while PayWhirl runs on Shopify only.

Choose PayWhirl if

  • you want to start free and pay $9 a month when you upgrade
  • you want phone support on every plan
Read the full PayWhirl details

Choose Recharge if

  • you sell on BigCommerce as well as Shopify
  • you want bundles, tiered discounts and A/B testing on one plan
Read the full Recharge details

PayWhirl vs Recharge at a glance

ComparePayWhirlRecharge
EcomBeats score6.7 out of 10Not rated yet
Rating on the Shopify App Store4.7 stars from 191 reviews4.8 stars from 3,161 reviews
Free planFree plan, $0 a monthNo free plan
Cheapest paid plan$9 a month (Pro)$149 a month (Starter)
Free trial14 days on paid plans60 days on Starter
Lowest transaction fee0.75% per order (Scale, $149 a month)1.25% + 20 cents per transaction (Scale, $499 a month)
Transaction fee on cheapest paid plan2% per order (Pro)1.50% + 20 cents per transaction (Starter)
Workflow automation from$29 a month (Traction)$149 a month (Starter)
BundlesNot listed on the pricing pageScale, $499 a month
Customer portalIncluded on every planIncluded on every plan
Failed-payment recoveryAutomatic retries on every plan; actions from TractionFailed Payment Recovery on Starter, listed as recovering up to 88% of failed payments
Support channelsPhone, chat and email on every planChat and email, 24/7, on every plan
First response timeNot published8 hours on Starter, 6 hours on Scale, 4 hours on Custom
PlatformsShopify onlyShopify and BigCommerce
APIs and developer accessTraction, $29 a monthJavascript SDK and Storefront API on Scale, $499 a month
Gift subscriptionsIncluded on every planSurprise and delight gifting on Scale, $499 a month
SMS subscription managementNot listed on the pricing pageConcierge SMS on Scale, $499 a month
A/B testingNot listed on the pricing pageSubscriber journey A/B testing on Scale, $499 a month
AI agentNot listed on the pricing pageRemi AI agent on Scale, $499 a month
Links

Source: PayWhirl Subscriptions on the Shopify App Store, Recharge Subscriptions App on the Shopify App Store, Recharge billing and pricing, PayWhirl subscription pricing and Recharge subscription pricing plans. The EcomBeats score averages pricing, features, support and merchant reviews, each out of 10. How we rate

What PayWhirl does

PayWhirl is a Shopify subscription app built to grow recurring revenue. Merchants create flexible subscription plans, sell subscriptions on product pages and carts, and manage subscriptions in customer accounts with no coding required.

Advanced tools include APIs, webhooks, and custom workflows. Support is US-based and available by phone, chat, or email, and the app helps migrate subscriptions from ReCharge, Appstle, Bold, Seal, and other subscription apps.

PayWhirl pricing

There is a free plan and three paid plans. Paid plans list a 14-day free trial. Paid plans start at $9/month.

Free
$0
Pro
$9/mo
Traction
$29/mo
Scale
$149/mo
Every PayWhirl plan and what each includes

Who PayWhirl suits

A good fit if

  • You want to start free and pay $9 a month when you upgrade.
  • You want phone support on every plan.
  • You want workflow automation, APIs and webhooks from $29 a month.
  • You are moving from Recharge and want migration help at no separate fee.

Limits

  • Every plan charges a transaction fee on subscription orders, from 3% on Free down to 0.75% on Scale.
  • Workflow automation, APIs and webhooks need the $29 Traction plan or higher.
  • Klaviyo integration and inventory tools are not on the Free or Pro plans.
  • The listing shows only English as a supported language.

Source: PayWhirl Subscriptions - Shopify App Store and Shopify Subscription App Pricing - PayWhirl.

Try PayWhirl free

Free plan: Free to install with a 3% transaction fee after the first $5,000 processed at 0%., paid from $9/month

What Recharge does

Recharge is a subscription platform for Shopify stores. It runs recurring billing through a subscription-first product page widget and a no-code customer portal where subscribers manage their own subscriptions. The listing describes it as a platform that grows recurring revenue by improving the subscriber lifecycle, from first subscription through cancellation prevention and win-back.

Starter costs $149 a month plus 1.50% + 20¢ per transaction and includes the widget, the portal, upsell and cross-sell tools, Smart Cancellation Prevention, Failed Payment Recovery, Win Back and automated workflows, with a 60-day free trial. Scale costs $499 a month plus 1.25% + 20¢ per transaction and adds bundles, tiered discounts, gifting, subscriber journey A/B testing, the Remi AI agent, Concierge SMS and the Javascript SDK and Storefront API. Custom has volume-based rates set in the contract.

Support runs 24 hours a day, 7 days a week on every plan, with chat and email support. The initial response time is 8 hours on Starter, 6 hours on Scale, and 4 hours on Custom, which adds live video callback support. Loyalty, covering credits, tiers and referrals, is an add-on billed as a separate line item.

Recharge pricing

There is a free plan and three paid plans. Paid plans list a 60-day free trial. Paid plans start at $149/month.

Starter
$149/mo
Scale
$499/mo
Custom
Custom
Every Recharge plan and what each includes

Who Recharge suits

A good fit if

  • You sell on BigCommerce as well as Shopify.
  • You want bundles, tiered discounts and A/B testing on one plan.
  • You want a 60-day free trial before the first bill.
  • You want 24/7 chat support with a published 8-hour first response on Starter.

Limits

  • Every transaction also costs 1.50% + 20¢ on Starter and 1.25% + 20¢ on Scale, on top of the monthly fee, including refunded orders.
  • There is no free plan; the only way to try Recharge without paying is the 60-day free trial on Starter.
  • Bundles, tiered discounts, gifting and subscriber journey A/B testing need Scale at $499 a month.
  • Loyalty, covering credits, tiers and referrals, is a paid add-on billed as a separate line item, not part of any plan.
  • The 25-50 plan is closed to new stores, so small stores start at $149 a month.

Source: Recharge Subscriptions App on the Shopify App Store, Subscription pricing plans for every stage of growth | Recharge and Recharge billing and pricing.

Try Recharge free

60-day free trial, paid from $149/month

Pricing compared

Each tool's plans side by side, as monthly prices on monthly billing.

PayWhirl plans

Free
0% fee on the first $5,000 processed, then 3% per subscription order
$0
Pro Lowest price
2% transaction fee
$9
Traction
1.5% transaction fee
$29
Scale
0.75% transaction fee
$149
All PayWhirl plans

Recharge plans

Starter Lowest price
$149 a month plus 1.50% + 20¢ per transaction; 60-day free trial; month-to-month.
$149
Scale
$499 a month plus 1.25% + 20¢ per transaction, with scalable transaction rates; Concierge SMS $0.03 per message segment in the US and Canada, $0.06 internationally.
$499
Custom
Volume-based rates set in the contract; 12-month term.
Custom
All Recharge plans

Monthly prices from PayWhirl Subscriptions on the Shopify App Store, PayWhirl subscription pricing, Recharge Subscriptions App on the Shopify App Store, Recharge subscription pricing plans and Recharge billing and pricing.

How they differ as you grow

What each upgrade adds

PayWhirl
Pro
Everything in Free, customizable email templates, automatic address updating, faster support
$9
Traction
Everything in Pro, workflow automation suite, failed payment actions, inventory management, klaviyo integration, API and webhooks
$29
Scale
Everything in Traction, High-volume transaction rate, dedicated account manager, First-priority support
$149
Recharge
Starter
Subscription-first product page widget, No-code customer portal, upsell & cross-sell tools, Smart Cancellation Prevention, Failed Payment Recovery, Win Back solutions, automated workflows, analytics & industry benchmarks
$149
Scale
Everything in Starter, Hands-on implementation, End-to-end migration support, customizable bundles, tiered discounts, surprise & delight gifting, subscriber journey A/B testing, Remi AI agent, Concierge SMS, Javascript SDK & Storefront API
$499
Custom
Custom implementations, dedicated priority technical support, review of solution architecture, enterprise business reviews
Custom

The bill starts $140 a month apart

PayWhirl starts free and its first paid plan, Pro, costs $9 a month, while Recharge has no free plan and Starter costs $149 a month, a gap of $140 a month at the door. At 100 orders a month with a $50 average order, PayWhirl Pro costs $109 against $244 for Recharge Starter. At 1,000 orders the same math gives $1,009 against $1,099. Recharge Starter only passes PayWhirl Pro past 2,800 orders a month at that average order, and PayWhirl Traction at $29 a month charges the same 1.5% rate as Starter, so it stays cheaper at every volume. PayWhirl Scale costs $149 a month, the same as Recharge Starter, with a lower 0.75% rate.

Automation and growth tools sit on very different tiers

The tools that grow a subscription program sit on very different tiers. PayWhirl puts workflow automation, failed-payment actions, inventory tools, Klaviyo integration, APIs and webhooks on Traction at $29 a month. Recharge keeps bundles, tiered discounts, gifting, subscriber journey A/B testing, the Remi AI agent and Concierge SMS for Scale at $499 a month, a gap of $470 a month between the two tiers. Recharge Starter at $149 a month does include automated workflows, the customer portal and failed-payment recovery, so the gap is about growth tools, not the basics.

A free plan against a 60-day trial

PayWhirl lets a store start without paying: the free plan covers unlimited subscriptions and orders, charging 0% on the first $5,000 processed and 3% per subscription order after that. Recharge has no free plan, so the only way in is the 60-day free trial on Starter. That trial is 46 days longer than the 14-day trial on PayWhirl paid plans, so Recharge gives a new store more time to test the full feature set before the first bill. Pick the free start if you want to prove the offer first; pick the long trial if you need every Starter feature from day one.

Support, migration and the platforms they cover

PayWhirl lists US-based support by phone, chat and email on every plan, with first-priority support and a dedicated account manager on Scale. Recharge lists 24/7 chat and email support on every plan, with a first response in 8 hours on Starter, 6 hours on Scale and 4 hours on Custom, which adds live video callback support. PayWhirl also offers migration help from Recharge and other apps at no separate fee, while Recharge puts end-to-end migration support on Scale. Recharge runs on Shopify and BigCommerce; PayWhirl runs on Shopify only.

Ratings from very different review counts

PayWhirl rates 4.7 stars from 191 reviews on the Shopify App Store, against 4.8 stars from 3,161 reviews for Recharge. The gap in stars is small, and the counts behind it are not: Recharge has more than 16 times as many reviews, so its 4.8 rests on far more stores. Read the stars with the counts beside them, not on their own.

Source: PayWhirl Subscriptions on the Shopify App Store, PayWhirl subscription pricing, Recharge billing and pricing, Recharge subscription pricing plans and Recharge Subscriptions App on the Shopify App Store.

Support and languages

DetailPayWhirlRecharge
Live chatChat support on every plan, plus phone and email support24/7 chat support on every plan
Top-plan supportFirst-priority support and a dedicated account manager on ScaleCustom adds video callback support and a 4-hour initial response time
App languages1: EnglishNot listed
DeveloperPayWhirl Inc., United StatesRecharge, Santa Monica, CA, US

Source: PayWhirl Subscriptions - Shopify App Store, Shopify Subscription App Pricing - PayWhirl, Recharge Subscriptions App on the Shopify App Store, Subscription pricing plans for every stage of growth | Recharge and Recharge billing and pricing.

Common questions

Which is cheaper, PayWhirl or Recharge?

PayWhirl is cheaper at every tier up to very high volume. Paid plans start at $9 a month against $149 for Recharge Starter, and PayWhirl Pro costs $109 a month against $244 for Recharge Starter at 100 orders with a $50 average order. Recharge Starter only passes PayWhirl Pro past 2,800 orders a month at that average order.

Does PayWhirl have a free plan?

Yes. PayWhirl has a free plan with unlimited subscriptions and orders, charging 0% on the first $5,000 processed and 3% per subscription order after that. Recharge has no free plan.

Does Recharge have a free plan?

No. Recharge has no free plan. The only way to try it without paying is the 60-day free trial on the Starter plan.

Which tool charges lower transaction fees?

PayWhirl. Its lowest fee is 0.75% per order on Scale at $149 a month, against 1.25% + 20¢ per transaction on Recharge Scale at $499 a month. On the cheapest paid plans, PayWhirl Pro charges 2% and Recharge Starter charges 1.50% + 20¢.

Can PayWhirl migrate subscriptions from Recharge?

Yes. PayWhirl offers migration help from Recharge and other subscription apps at no separate fee. Recharge offers end-to-end migration support on its Scale plan at $499 a month.

Which tool works on BigCommerce?

Recharge. It runs on Shopify and BigCommerce. PayWhirl runs on Shopify only.

Sources

Prices, plans, ratings and features on this page come from these sources. Found something out of date? Tell us.

Keep comparing

6

Browse
Categories