EcomBeatsSearch tools and comparisonsCtrl KSubmit a tool

Recharge

Recharge runs subscriptions for Shopify stores with a no-code customer portal, cancellation prevention and failed-payment recovery, from $149 a month plus transaction fees.

Rated 4.8 out of 5 from 3,161 reviews on the Shopify App Store

Recharge alternatives: 5 subscription apps compared

Loop Subscriptions is the closest swap for Recharge at $99 a month, with bundles, cancellation flows and a customer portal, against $149 a month for Recharge Starter. Seal Subscriptions is the budget pick, with a free plan for 50 subscriptions and paid plans from $5.95 a month at a 0% transaction fee. Appstle, Kaching and Skio cover free starts, flat pricing and premium retention.

Recharge Starter
$149/moits cheapest paid plan
Lowest paid plan
$5.95/moSeal Subscriptions SUPERSALE
Unlimited pages from
$99/moLoop Subscriptions Starter

Quick comparison

Recharge and its alternatives compared
AppRechargeYour current appAppstle SubscriptionsKaching SubscriptionsLoop SubscriptionsSeal SubscriptionsSkio
Rating4.83,161 reviews5.09,307 reviews5.01,236 reviews4.9819 reviews4.93,188 reviews5.0249 reviews
EcomBeats scoreNot rated yet8.5 out of 107.3 out of 106.8 out of 10Not rated yetNot rated yet
Rating4.8 stars from 3,161 reviews5.0 stars from 9,307 reviews5.0 stars from 1,236 reviews4.9 stars from 819 reviews4.9 stars from 3,188 reviews5.0 stars from 249 reviews
Cheapest paid plan$149 a monthStarter$10 a monthStarter$9.99 a monthStarterFrom $99 a monthStarter$5.95 a monthSUPERSALE$599 a monthScale
What the cheapest paid plan includesWidget, no-code portal, Smart Cancellation Prevention, Failed Payment Recovery, Win Back and automated workflows.Up to $5,000 a month in subscriptions, native portal, payment retry, analytics and churn control.Up to $1,000 a month in subscriptions, with every feature and no transaction fee.Unlimited subscriptions, bundles, cancellation flows, smart dunning and the portal.100 subscriptions, auto-charging, recurring invoices, dunning and the customer portal.No-code portal, Build-a-Box, cancel flows, lifecycle journeys, analytics and payment recovery.
Free plan that publishesNo free plan; 60-day trial on Starter.Free, up to $500 a month in subscriptions.No free plan for a live store; free for development stores only.Free, up to 50 active subscriptions.Free, up to 50 total subscriptions.No free plan.
Free trial60 days14 days14 days14 days30 daysNot listed
Transaction fee1.50% + 20¢ per transaction on Starter.0% on every plan.No transaction fee on any plan.1.0% per transaction on Starter.0% on every plan.1.25% + 20¢ per transaction.
Cancellation save flowsSmart Cancellation Prevention on Starter.Churn control on every plan.Subscribers pause, skip, swap or cancel in the portal.Personalised cancellation flows on Starter.Cancellation flow from Rising Star ($9.95).Multi-step cancel flows on Scale.
Build-a-box bundlesBundles on Scale ($499).Build-a-box from Business ($30).Subscription options inside Kaching Bundles tiers.Fixed and build-your-own bundles on Starter.Not listed.Build-a-Box on Scale.
Failed payment recoveryFailed Payment Recovery on Starter.Payment retry on every plan.Declined renewals retried up to 5 times, 3 days apart.Smart dunning management on Starter.Dunning management on every plan.Payment recovery campaigns on Scale.
Customer portalNo-code portal; subscribers manage subscriptions.Shopify native portal; passwordless login from Starter.Portal to pause, skip, swap and cancel.Branded portal; skip, swap, pause and update payment.Passwordless portal; manage, pause or cancel.No-code portal with passwordless login.
SupportChat and email support, 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, on every plan.24/7 human support in minutes on every plan.24/7 live support on every plan.Chat support for all users; dedicated success manager on Pro.Support on every plan; phone support on Mega Star and Superstar.Dedicated Merchant Success Manager on Enterprise.
Highest planCustom, volume-based rates set in the contract.Business Premium, $100 a month for up to $100,000 a month in subscriptions.Growth, $24.99 a month for up to $10,000 a month in subscriptions.Enterprise, custom pricing.Superstar, $399 a month for 150,000 subscriptions.Enterprise, custom pricing.
Compare–––vs Recharge: Loop Subscriptions compared with Rechargevs Recharge: Seal Subscriptions compared with Rechargevs Recharge: Skio compared with Recharge
VisitVisit Visit Visit Visit Visit Visit

Starting price

Seal Subscriptions$5.95/mo
Kaching Subscriptions$9.99/mo
Appstle Subscriptions$10/mo
Loop Subscriptions$99/mo
Recharge$149/mo
Skio$599/mo

Source: the sources listed at the end of this page. Prices are monthly, in USD. The EcomBeats score averages pricing, features, support and merchant reviews, each out of 10. How we rate

The 5 alternatives

Ordered by EcomBeats score, highest first. Apps without a score come last. How we rate

1. Appstle Subscriptions

5.0 9,307 reviews

A free plan with no transaction fee

Appstle Subscriptions runs pay-as-you-go and prepaid subscriptions for Shopify stores, with build-a-box bundles from the $30 Business plan, and the free plan covers up to $500 a month in subscription sales. Paid plans start at $10 a month for up to $5,000 a month in subscription revenue, and every plan charges a 0% transaction fee. Every plan includes a Shopify native customer portal, payment retry, analytics and churn control, with 24/7 human support in minutes.

What stands out

  • Free plan covers up to $500 a month in subscription sales, with migration help and a native customer portal.
  • Paid plans charge a 0% transaction fee, and yearly billing saves 20% on every paid plan.
  • 5.0 stars from 9,307 reviews on the Shopify App Store.
  • 14-day free trial on all three paid plans, from $10 a month on Starter.

Drawbacks

  • The free plan caps subscription sales at $500 a month, and each paid plan has its own monthly revenue cap, up to $100,000 a month on Business Premium.
  • Loyalty features, inventory forecast and SMS notifications need a paid plan, starting at $10 a month.
  • Only English is listed as a supported language.
Free plan: Free plan covers up to $500 in subscriptions per month.Score 8.5 out of 10

2. Kaching Subscriptions

5.0 1,236 reviews

Every feature for one flat price

Kaching Subscriptions adds pay-per-delivery and prepaid subscriptions to a Shopify store from $9.99 a month, with no transaction fee on any plan. Every plan includes the same features, and the price only rises when monthly subscription revenue crosses a tier: Starter covers up to $1,000 a month, Basic up to $3,000, and Growth up to $10,000. Declined renewals are retried up to 5 times, 3 days apart, and subscribers pause, skip, swap or cancel in a portal.

What stands out

  • Every plan includes every feature from $9.99 a month, with no transaction fee on any plan.
  • Declined renewals are retried up to 5 times, 3 days apart.
  • Rated 5.0 from 1,236 reviews on the Shopify App Store, with 99% of ratings at 5 stars.
  • Subscribers pause, skip, swap or cancel on their own in a portal.

Drawbacks

  • The top plan, Growth at $24.99 a month, stops at $10,000 a month in subscription revenue, and the listing shows no higher tier for stores above that.
  • There is no free plan for a live store; development stores are free, and a live store pays from $9.99 a month after the 14-day trial.
  • The price rises with subscription revenue: a store crossing $1,000 a month moves from $9.99 to $14.99, and past $3,000 to $24.99.
Free plan: Free for development stores only; a live store needs a paid plan after the 14-day free trial.Score 7.3 out of 10

3. Loop Subscriptions

4.9 819 reviews

The closest swap for Recharge

Loop Subscriptions runs Shopify subscriptions with bundles, cancellation flows and a customer portal, from $99 a month plus a transaction fee, against $149 a month for Recharge Starter. The free plan covers up to 50 active subscriptions, and Starter adds unlimited subscriptions, bundles, cancellation flows and smart dunning management. White-glove migration is included on every paid plan, with no setup fee, and Pro at $399 a month adds prepaid and gift subscriptions, API and webhook access, and a dedicated customer success manager. Enterprise has custom pricing.

What stands out

  • Free plan covers up to 50 active subscriptions, so a store can start selling subscriptions without a monthly fee.
  • Starter at $99 a month includes unlimited subscriptions, bundles, cancellation flows and smart dunning management.
  • White-glove migration is included on every paid plan, with no setup or migration fee.
  • Pro adds prepaid and gift subscriptions, API and webhook access, and a dedicated customer success manager.

Drawbacks

  • The 1.0% transaction fee on Starter and 0.75% on Pro sits on top of the monthly fee, so the monthly cost rises with subscription revenue.
  • API and webhook access, prepaid and gift subscriptions, and a dedicated customer success manager need Pro at $399 a month, not Starter.
  • Loyalty orders add 15¢ each on Starter and 10¢ each on Pro, on top of the percentage transaction fee.
Free plan: Up to 50 active subscriptions, with a mobile-friendly customer portal, customer alerts for subscription updates, and subscription growth and revenue analytics.Score 6.8 out of 10

4. Seal Subscriptions

4.9 3,188 reviews

The lowest paid price

Seal Subscriptions adds recurring billing to a Shopify store with a free plan for 50 subscriptions and paid plans from $5.95 a month, and every plan charges a 0% transaction fee. Plans are priced by the number of subscriptions, from 50 on the free plan to 150,000 on Superstar at $399 a month, with Leader at $89.95 and Mega Star at $199 in between. The pricing page lists a cancellation flow from Rising Star at $9.95 a month, and paid plans include a 30-day free trial.

What stands out

  • Free plan covers 50 subscriptions with a 0% transaction fee.
  • Paid plans start at $5.95 a month, the lowest here.
  • Plans scale from 50 to 150,000 subscriptions without changing tools.

Drawbacks

  • The free plan caps at 50 subscriptions, and each paid plan has its own subscription cap.
  • Klaviyo integration, fixed schedules and the subscribe now button start on Legend at $24.95 a month, not on the cheaper plans.
  • Phone support appears only on the Mega Star and Superstar plans.
Free plan: Free for up to 50 total subscriptions, with a 0% transaction fee, auto-charging and full API and webhooks access.

5. Skio

5.0 249 reviews

Every feature in one premium plan

From $599/moVisit Skio

Skio is a subscription platform for Shopify brands with a no-code customer portal, Build-a-Box and payment recovery from $599 a month, against $149 a month for Recharge Starter. The Scale plan includes every feature the pricing page lists, from the no-code customer portal to payment recovery, with multi-step cancel flows and automated lifecycle journeys. Skio is listed as a Recharge company, and its Enterprise plan has custom pricing for high-volume merchants.

What stands out

  • The Scale plan includes every feature the pricing page lists, from the no-code customer portal to payment recovery.
  • Rated 5.0 stars across 249 reviews on the Shopify App Store.
  • Annual billing costs $5,988 a year.
  • Skio states it moves 50,000 or more subscribers during migration.

Drawbacks

  • Scale starts at $599 a month, with no lower-priced plan for small stores.
  • A 1.25% plus 20-cent transaction fee applies to every order involving a subscription, on top of the monthly price.
  • There is no free plan, and no free trial is listed on the pricing page or the listing.
  • Loyalty rewards start at $549 a month, sold separately from Scale and Enterprise.
No free plan; the Scale plan starts at $599 a month.

Source: the sources listed at the end of this page. Prices are monthly, in USD.

Why people look elsewhere

Starter costs $149 a month, plus a fee on every order

Recharge Starter costs $149 a month plus 1.50% + 20¢ per transaction, and the fee applies to every order including refunded ones. The old 25-50 plan is closed to new stores, so a small store cannot start below $149 a month. Seal Subscriptions starts paid plans at $5.95 a month with a 0% transaction fee, and Appstle Subscriptions starts at $10 a month with a 0% fee.

Bundles and retention tools need the $499 Scale plan

Bundles, tiered discounts, gifting and subscriber journey A/B testing need Scale at $499 a month, and the Remi AI agent and Concierge SMS sit on Scale too. Loop Subscriptions includes bundles and cancellation flows on Starter at $99 a month, and Skio includes Build-a-Box, cancel flows and payment recovery in its single $599 Scale plan.

Loyalty costs extra as a separate add-on

Loyalty, covering credits, tiers and referrals, is an add-on billed as a separate line item, not part of any Recharge plan. Seal Subscriptions includes loyalty discounts from Leader at $89.95 a month, and Loop Subscriptions builds loyalty into its cancellation flows, portal and storefront on Starter at $99 a month.

No free plan, only a 60-day trial

Recharge has no free plan; the only way to try it without paying is the 60-day free trial on Starter. Appstle Subscriptions has a free plan for up to $500 a month in subscription sales, Seal Subscriptions has a free plan for 50 subscriptions, and Loop Subscriptions has a free plan for 50 active subscriptions.

Source: the sources listed at the end of this page.

How to choose

Source: the sources listed at the end of this page.

When to stay with Recharge

Stay on Recharge if the subscription program is large enough to carry $149 a month plus transaction fees, since Starter includes the no-code customer portal, Smart Cancellation Prevention, Failed Payment Recovery and Win Back, with 24/7 chat and email support and a 60-day free trial. Scale at $499 a month adds bundles, tiered discounts, gifting, A/B testing, the Remi AI agent and Concierge SMS in one place.

Source: Recharge Subscriptions App on the Shopify App Store.

Common questions

Which Recharge alternative is the cheapest?

Seal Subscriptions is the cheapest: paid plans start at $5.95 a month with a 0% transaction fee, and the free plan covers 50 subscriptions. The cheapest paid Recharge plan is Starter at $149 a month.

Which Recharge alternative is the closest swap?

Loop Subscriptions is the closest swap: Starter costs $99 a month and includes unlimited subscriptions, bundles, cancellation flows and smart dunning, against $149 a month for Recharge Starter. Loop also has a free plan for 50 active subscriptions.

Which Recharge alternatives charge no transaction fee?

Seal Subscriptions, Appstle Subscriptions and Kaching Subscriptions charge a 0% transaction fee on every plan. Recharge charges 1.50% + 20¢ per transaction on Starter and 1.25% + 20¢ on Scale.

Which Recharge alternatives have a free plan?

Seal Subscriptions, Appstle Subscriptions and Loop Subscriptions have a free plan you can publish with: Seal covers 50 subscriptions, Appstle covers up to $500 a month in subscription sales, and Loop covers 50 active subscriptions. Kaching is free for development stores only, and Recharge and Skio have no free plan.

Which Recharge alternative has Build-a-Box?

Skio includes Build-a-Box on Scale at $599 a month, Appstle includes build-a-box bundles from Business at $30 a month, and Loop includes fixed and build-your-own bundles on Starter at $99 a month. Recharge keeps bundles for Scale at $499 a month.

Is Skio more expensive than Recharge?

Yes. Skio Scale costs $599 a month plus a 1.25% + 20¢ transaction fee, against $149 a month plus 1.50% + 20¢ for Recharge Starter. Skio is the premium pick here, with every feature in one plan and no lower-priced tier.

Can I switch from Recharge without losing subscribers?

Loop Subscriptions includes white-glove migration on every paid plan, with no setup or migration fee, and Appstle Subscriptions includes migration help on every plan. Both tools state they move stores from another subscription app.

Sources

Star ratings come from the Shopify App Store. EcomBeats scores are worked out from the same listings. How we rate

Keep comparing

Browse
Categories