Recharge vs Seal Subscriptions: prices compared
Seal Subscriptions
Short answer
- Starting subscriptions on a small budget
- S
Seal Subscriptions Supersale costs $5.95 a month with no transaction fee, against $149 a month plus 1.50% + 20¢ per transaction for Recharge Starter, and the free plan covers 50 subscriptions.
- Selling subscriptions without paying a transaction fee
- S
Seal Subscriptions Seal Subscriptions charges a 0% transaction fee on every plan, while Recharge charges 1.50% + 20¢ per transaction on Starter and 1.25% + 20¢ on Scale.
- Running advanced retention tools in one plan
- R
Recharge Scale at $499 a month adds bundles, tiered discounts, gifting, subscriber journey A/B testing, the Remi AI agent and Concierge SMS.
- Selling on BigCommerce as well as Shopify
- R
Recharge Recharge runs on Shopify and BigCommerce, while Seal Subscriptions runs only on Shopify.
- Trying the tool before paying, for the longest
- R
Recharge Starter includes a 60-day free trial, while Seal Subscriptions offers a 30-day free trial on paid plans.
- The highest star rating
- S
Seal Subscriptions Seal Subscriptions rates 4.9 stars from 3,188 reviews, against 4.8 stars from 3,161 reviews for Recharge.
Pick Seal Subscriptions to start subscriptions for less: Supersale costs $5.95 a month with no transaction fee, against $149 a month plus 1.50% + 20¢ per transaction for Recharge Starter, and the free plan covers 50 subscriptions. Pick Recharge for deeper retention tools: Scale adds bundles, A/B testing, the Remi AI agent and Concierge SMS for $499 a month, with a 60-day trial and 24/7 support. Seal Subscriptions rates higher at 4.9 stars against 4.8.
Choose Recharge if
- you want the longest free trial at 60 days
- you sell on BigCommerce as well as Shopify
Choose Seal Subscriptions if
- you want a free plan for up to 50 subscriptions
- you want a 0% transaction fee on every plan
Recharge vs Seal Subscriptions at a glance
| Compare | Recharge | Seal Subscriptions |
|---|---|---|
| Cheapest paid plan | $149/mo (Starter) | $5.95/mo (Supersale) |
| Free plan | None | Free, 50 subscriptions |
| Free trial | 60 days (Starter) | 30 days (paid plans) |
| Transaction fee on cheapest plan | 1.50% + 20¢ | 0% |
| Monthly fee at 500 subscriptions | $149/mo plus 1.50% + 20¢ | $24.95/mo, no fee |
| Highest plan | Custom, volume-based rates | $399/mo (Superstar) |
| Yearly billing | No yearly price listed | 20% saving; Legend $239.52 a year |
| Rating | 4.8 stars (3,161 reviews) | 4.9 stars (3,188 reviews) |
| Bundles | Customizable bundles on Scale at $499/mo | Not listed |
| Subscriber journey A/B testing | On Scale at $499/mo | Not listed |
| AI agent | Remi AI agent on Scale at $499/mo | Not listed |
| SMS subscription management | Concierge SMS on Scale at $499/mo | Not listed |
| Fixed schedules | Not listed | On Legend at $24.95/mo |
| Subscription discounts | Tiered discounts on Scale at $499/mo | On every plan, free included |
| Cancellation flow | Smart Cancellation Prevention on every plan | Cancellation flow from Rising Star at $9.95/mo |
| Prepaid subscriptions | Not listed | On every plan |
| Klaviyo integration | Not listed | On Legend at $24.95/mo |
| Languages listed | Not listed | 18 languages |
| Loyalty | Paid add-on, billed separately | Loyalty discounts from Leader at $89.95/mo |
| Migration | End-to-end migration support on Scale | Not listed |
| Support hours | 24/7 chat and email on every plan | Not listed |
| Platforms | Shopify and BigCommerce | Shopify only |
| Links |
Source: Recharge Subscriptions App on the Shopify App Store, Seal Subscriptions App on the Shopify App Store, Recharge pricing plans and Seal Subscriptions pricing.
Recharge
Plans and featuresWhat Recharge does
Recharge is a subscription platform for Shopify stores. It runs recurring billing through a subscription-first product page widget and a no-code customer portal where subscribers manage their own subscriptions. The listing describes it as a platform that grows recurring revenue by improving the subscriber lifecycle, from first subscription through cancellation prevention and win-back.
Starter costs $149 a month plus 1.50% + 20¢ per transaction and includes the widget, the portal, upsell and cross-sell tools, Smart Cancellation Prevention, Failed Payment Recovery, Win Back and automated workflows, with a 60-day free trial. Scale costs $499 a month plus 1.25% + 20¢ per transaction and adds bundles, tiered discounts, gifting, subscriber journey A/B testing, the Remi AI agent, Concierge SMS and the Javascript SDK and Storefront API. Custom has volume-based rates set in the contract.
Support runs 24 hours a day, 7 days a week on every plan, with chat and email support. The initial response time is 8 hours on Starter, 6 hours on Scale, and 4 hours on Custom, which adds live video callback support. Loyalty, covering credits, tiers and referrals, is an add-on billed as a separate line item.
Recharge pricing
There is a free plan and three paid plans. Paid plans list a 60-day free trial. Paid plans start at $149/month.
- Starter
- $149/mo
- Scale
- $499/mo
- Custom
- Custom
Who Recharge suits
A good fit if
- You want the longest free trial at 60 days.
- You sell on BigCommerce as well as Shopify.
- You want bundles, A/B testing, the Remi AI agent and Concierge SMS on one plan.
- You want 24/7 chat and email support on every plan.
Limits
- Every transaction also costs 1.50% + 20¢ on Starter and 1.25% + 20¢ on Scale, on top of the monthly fee.
- There is no free plan; the only way to try Recharge without paying is the 60-day free trial on Starter.
- Bundles, tiered discounts, gifting and A/B testing need Scale at $499 a month.
- Loyalty costs extra as a separate add-on, not part of any plan.
- Rated 4.8 stars, below Seal Subscriptions at 4.9 stars.
Source: Recharge Subscriptions App on the Shopify App Store, Subscription pricing plans for every stage of growth | Recharge and Recharge billing and pricing.
Try Recharge free
60-day free trial, paid from $149/month
Seal Subscriptions
Plans and featuresWhat Seal Subscriptions does
Seal Subscriptions is a Shopify app for selling products on a repeating schedule. It charges customers automatically, sends recurring invoices and lets shoppers manage subscriptions from a customer portal, with product swaps, tiered discounts and multi-language translations on every plan.
Plans are priced by the number of subscriptions, from a free plan for 50 subscriptions to Superstar for 150,000, and every plan charges a 0% transaction fee. Paid plans include a 30-day free trial, and yearly billing saves 20%.
Seal Subscriptions pricing
There is a free plan and three paid plans. Paid plans list a 30-day free trial. Paid plans start at $5.95/month.
- Free
- $0
- Supersale
- $5.95/mo
- Rising Star
- $9.95/mo
- Legend
- $24.95/mo
Who Seal Subscriptions suits
A good fit if
- You want a free plan for up to 50 subscriptions.
- You want a 0% transaction fee on every plan.
- You want paid plans from $5.95 a month.
- You want the higher star rating at 4.9 stars.
Limits
- Klaviyo integration, fixed schedules and the subscribe now button start on Legend at $24.95 a month, not on the cheaper plans.
- Phone support appears only on the Mega Star and Superstar plans, from $199 a month.
- Seal Subscriptions works only with Shopify, so stores on other platforms cannot use it.
- The top plans jump sharply in price: Legend is $24.95 a month for 500 subscriptions, while Leader is $89.95 for 2,000.
- No bundles, A/B testing, AI agent or SMS management is listed on any plan.
Source: Seal Subscriptions on the Shopify App Store, Seal Subscriptions pricing and Seal Subscriptions homepage.
Try Seal Subscriptions free
Free plan: Free for up to 50 total subscriptions, with a 0% transaction fee, auto-charging and full API and webhooks access., paid from $5.95/month
Pricing compared
Each tool's plans side by side, as monthly prices on monthly billing.
Recharge plans
Seal Subscriptions plans
Monthly prices from Recharge Subscriptions App on the Shopify App Store, Recharge pricing plans, Seal Subscriptions App on the Shopify App Store and Seal Subscriptions pricing.
How they differ as you grow
What each upgrade adds
The entry bill starts $143.05 a month apart
Seal Subscriptions Supersale costs $5.95 a month, while Recharge Starter costs $149 a month, so the gap at the door is $143.05 a month. Seal Subscriptions also runs a free plan for up to 50 subscriptions, while Recharge has no free plan. Yearly billing saves 20% on Seal Subscriptions: Legend costs $239.52 a year, which works out at $19.96 a month, against $24.95 a month on monthly billing. Recharge lists no yearly price. A store that wants the lowest bill to start picks Seal Subscriptions, while a store that wants the longest trial picks Recharge, with 60 days against 30.
A transaction fee against none
Recharge charges a fee on every transaction, on top of the monthly plan price: 1.50% + 20¢ on Starter and 1.25% + 20¢ on Scale, including refunded orders. Seal Subscriptions charges a 0% transaction fee on every plan, from the free plan to Superstar. The fee changes the bill at any volume: a store processing $10,000 a month in subscription payments owes $150 in fees on Recharge Starter, plus 20¢ per transaction, and nothing in fees on Seal Subscriptions. The fee alone can exceed the whole Seal Subscriptions bill.
Subscription caps against volume-based billing
Seal Subscriptions prices by the number of subscriptions: the free plan covers 50, Supersale 100, Rising Star 250, Legend 500, Leader 2,000, Mega Star 50,000 and Superstar 150,000. A store that outgrows a tier moves up to the next plan. Recharge lists no subscription-count cap: Starter and Scale charge a flat monthly fee plus a percentage of each transaction, so the bill grows with payment volume instead of subscription count. A store with many low-value subscriptions pays for count on Seal Subscriptions and for volume on Recharge.
Retention features sit on different tiers
Recharge puts its retention tools on Scale at $499 a month: customizable bundles, tiered discounts, surprise and delight gifting, subscriber journey A/B testing, the Remi AI agent and Concierge SMS. Starter at $149 a month covers the widget, the no-code portal, Smart Cancellation Prevention, Failed Payment Recovery and Win Back. Seal Subscriptions spreads its features lower: the free plan already includes subscription discounts and product swaps, automated interval changes start on Rising Star at $9.95 a month, and the Klaviyo integration, fixed schedules and the subscribe now button start on Legend at $24.95 a month. Loyalty discounts start on Leader at $89.95 a month. Loyalty costs extra on Recharge, billed as a separate add-on, while Seal Subscriptions includes loyalty discounts from Leader.
Support and platforms differ
Recharge includes 24/7 chat and email support on every plan, with a first response in 8 hours on Starter, 6 hours on Scale and 4 hours on Custom, which adds live video callback support. Seal Subscriptions lists no support hours: regular support runs on the free plan, priority support starts on Legend at $24.95 a month, and phone support appears only on Mega Star at $199 a month and Superstar. Recharge also runs on BigCommerce as well as Shopify, while Seal Subscriptions works only on Shopify.
Source: Recharge Subscriptions App on the Shopify App Store, Recharge pricing plans, Seal Subscriptions App on the Shopify App Store and Seal Subscriptions pricing.
Support and languages
| Detail | Recharge | Seal Subscriptions |
|---|---|---|
| Live chat | 24/7 chat support on every plan | Not listed |
| Top-plan support | Custom adds video callback support and a 4-hour initial response time | Not listed |
| App languages | Not listed | 18: English, Spanish, French, Portuguese (Brazil), Portuguese (Portugal), Polish, German, Dutch, Italian, Slovenian, Swedish, Turkish, Hebrew, Arabic, Japanese, Chinese (Simplified), Chinese (Traditional), Romanian |
| Developer | Recharge, Santa Monica, CA, US | Seal Subscriptions |
Source: Recharge Subscriptions App on the Shopify App Store, Subscription pricing plans for every stage of growth | Recharge, Recharge billing and pricing, Seal Subscriptions on the Shopify App Store, Seal Subscriptions pricing and Seal Subscriptions homepage.
Common questions
Which is cheaper, Recharge or Seal Subscriptions?
Seal Subscriptions costs less in monthly fees on the listed tiers: Supersale is $5.95 a month against $149 for Recharge Starter, and Superstar is $399 a month against $499 for Recharge Scale. Seal Subscriptions also charges no transaction fee, while Recharge charges 1.50% + 20¢ on Starter and 1.25% + 20¢ on Scale.
Does Recharge or Seal Subscriptions offer a free plan?
Seal Subscriptions offers a free plan for up to 50 subscriptions with a 0% transaction fee. Recharge has no free plan; its Starter plan includes a 60-day free trial.
Do Recharge and Seal Subscriptions charge transaction fees?
Recharge charges 1.50% + 20¢ per transaction on Starter and 1.25% + 20¢ on Scale, on top of the monthly fee. Seal Subscriptions charges a 0% transaction fee on every plan.
Which has the higher rating, Recharge or Seal Subscriptions?
Seal Subscriptions rates 4.9 stars from 3,188 reviews, against 4.8 stars from 3,161 reviews for Recharge, both on the Shopify App Store.
Does Seal Subscriptions work with BigCommerce?
No, Seal Subscriptions works only with Shopify. Recharge works with Shopify and BigCommerce.
What does Recharge Scale add over Starter?
Scale adds bundles, tiered discounts, gifting, subscriber journey A/B testing, the Remi AI agent, Concierge SMS and the Javascript SDK and Storefront API for $499 a month.
How far do Seal Subscriptions plans scale?
Seal Subscriptions scales from 50 subscriptions on the free plan to 150,000 on Superstar at $399 a month, with Leader at $89.95 for 2,000 subscriptions and Mega Star at $199 for 50,000 in between.